We are athletes from Alaska, and we support transgender children playing sports on teams that align with their gender identity. Our backgrounds are diverse, ranging from K-12 to NCAA Division 1-level competitive sports and beyond. We believe all children deserve the same opportunities to play, lose, win and learn.
It can be hard to understand what it means to be transgender, especially if you’ve never met a transgender person. But we can all agree that transgender kids should be treated with dignity and respect, just like everyone else. Trans kids are kids, just like your kids and like the kid you used to be. Trans kids like all the same things those kids like. They like to learn, dance, play, sing and compete in sports.
In 2021, the Alaska Legislature proposed a statewide anti-trans sports ban that was stopped after overwhelming public testimony, and a similar ban by the Alaska School Activities Association was tabled after public testimony earlier this year. But now the Alaska Board of Education has proposed a similar regulation change that would violate every student’s privacy and prohibit trans children from playing sports on teams that match their gender identity. We want to encourage the Board of Education to consider how that change would hurt trans children and all of Alaska’s young people.
Every child deserves to know what it’s like to compete in sports. They deserve to learn what it’s like to be tied 24-24 in the third set of a volleyball game, or pushing to the limit to beat a personal record. They should know what it’s like to lift up and be lifted up by your teammates. They deserve the rush and euphoria of a hard-fought win! They also deserve to know what it’s like to have to ride the bus back home after their team didn’t play its best. They should have the opportunity to feel like they could have done better, to experience disappointment and to learn from it, to get back to practice with a supportive coach. These are experiences that any athlete knows. They are experiences that build character, fortitude and lifelong memories.
The purpose of school sports is not to train Olympians or elite athletes, although many Olympians and elite athletes may come out of Alaska’s K-12 sports teams. The purpose of K-12 sports in Alaska is to teach students skills like leadership, hard work, teamwork, inclusion, sportsmanship, self-discipline, perseverance and communication. Not only do trans students benefit from learning these skills, but their participation enriches those skills for others. Too often, though, requiring that a trans student compete with the sports team corresponding to their sex assigned at birth means that they don’t compete at all.
Cisgender students suffer under this policy as well, because enforcing the policy will require diminishing the privacy of all students in order to determine their sex assigned at birth. Every student is up for questioning or investigation by adults who should be there as trusted mentors, not gender police.
We urge the Alaska Department of Education to live its mission and continue to work towards providing an excellent experience for every student by not adopting the proposed regulation changes.
Isa Weiss, Division 1 gymnast
Ava Earl, Division 1 cross-country runner
Jenna DiFolco, former University of Alaska Anchorage cross-country skier
Kelly Meierotto, University of Alaska Swimming alumna
Sarah Mehl Histand, Alaskan mental health therapist and fitness trainer
Angelica Peger, president of Fairbanks Roller Derby
Bird Nelson, owner of Ascension Rock Club
Jade Bodenhamer, yoga instructor
Nolan Earnest, cross-country running
Justin Hannah, cross-country running
Brianna Silva, volleyball
Zoe Foshee, flag football
Bradley Cross, track and field
Kristina Miller, soccer
Roan Willson, alpine skiing
Julian Dann, biking
Hannah Kepner, rock climbing
Hunter Moeller, cross-country skiing
Hannah Chapman-Dutton, volleyball
David Song, tennis
Laura Weingartner, soccer
Anika Pinzner, field hockey
Colin Mckenzie, cross-country skiing
Kendell Macomber, aerial arts
Victoria Nelson, bowling
A. Hunter, taekwondo
Josef Maier, rock climbing
Hopelynn Uele, volleyball
Kuba Grzeda, cross-country running
Sarah Goetz, aerial arts
Morganne Armstrong, basketball
Reily Dixon, cross-country skiing
Issa Spatrisano, rugby
Erin I’nama, swimming
Frana Burtness-Adams, volleyball
Cora DeLaca, alpine skiing
Alanna Greenwell, cross-country running
Jennifer Campbell, basketball
Brandy Harty, cross-country skiing
Scott Joyce, basketball
Kristen Schupp, cross-country skiing
Wendy Berg, cross-country skiing
Nani Saunders, swimming
Jessica Maier, ice hockey
M. Szatkowski, cross-country running
Michelle Gavel, cycling
Jennifer Anderson
Andrew Pace, running
Kristin Knight Pace, long-distance dog mushing
Corrine Leistikow, M.D., cycling
Sara Mustard
Stevie Goetz, soccer
Drew Krull, soccer
Emma Zayon, cross-country running
Maggie Whitaker, cross-country skiing
Aurora Bowers, cross-country skiing
The views expressed here are the writer’s and are not necessarily endorsed by the Anchorage Daily News, which welcomes a broad range of viewpoints. To submit a piece for consideration, email commentary(at)adn.com. Send submissions shorter than 200 words to letters@adn.com or click here to submit via any web browser. Read our full guidelines for letters and commentaries here.