Nation/World

Women directors see little gains since 1998, report finds

From Ricky Gervais' joking about the issue at the Golden Globes Sunday night to Jennifer Lawrence penning an essay on the topic recently, the gender gap for on-screen stars is having a moment.

But the slow progress of women in the film industry's off-screen roles is worthy of attention, too. The latest update to the longest-running study on women in behind-the-scenes roles was released Tuesday, finding that the "Celluloid Ceiling," as the report is named, is still very much in place.

Martha Lauzen, executive director of the Center for the Study of Women in Television and Film at San Diego State University, found that among the top 250 domestic grossing films, women filled just 19 percent of the following pivotal movie-making jobs: director, writer, executive producer, editor and cinematographer.

While that's two percentage points higher than last year, it can't be called good news yet. That's because the figure, which is actually the same as the number seen in 2001, has fluctuated up and down by a couple percentage points for nearly 20 years. The same goes for the percentage of films directed by a woman, which is up slightly this year but exactly the same as the percentage of films directed by women back in 1998.

"It's not really a surprise to me because I've been doing this for 20 years," Lauzen said. "The percentage of women in these various roles will increase a couple of percentage points one year and decrease a couple the next--we tend to stay in a pretty narrow range. But it is a surprise that this is where we are in 2016, especially given all the public dialogue about this issue recently."

At Sunday night's Golden Globes, no women were nominated for best director, and only one woman was nominated for best screenplay (Emma Donoghue, "Room"). In the four years prior, only one woman was nominated for best screenplay and only two were nominated for best director.

Lauzen expanded the study this year to also analyze the number of women working behind the scenes on the top 100 and the top 500 grossing films, too. Those breakdowns were telling. In traditionally male roles -- directors, cinematographers, executive producers -- women were represented in far greater numbers when the sample size was larger, and more independent films are included. (She excludes foreign-language films to get a better reflection of U.S. jobs.)

ADVERTISEMENT

For instance, just three percent of the top 100 films have female cinematographers. But among the top 500, 10 percent are women.

The same pattern doesn't hold up in roles that have more traditionally been open to women, such as editing. Indeed, "for many years, editing was thought of as being like sewing," Lauzen said. "Small hands were thought to be good at cutting celluloid." While 20 percent of editors on the top 100 films are female, it's roughly the same in larger samples -- 22 percent of editors are women among the top 250 films, and 21 percent are female among the top 500.

That suggests, Lauzen said, that the more traditionally male roles are more susceptible to biases in the mainstream film industry that tend to produce the highest-grossing films. "People have this image in their head of 'that's what a director looks like,' " she said.

Lauzen also included a discussion in the report for the first time this year about how having a woman in the director role leads to more women filling other jobs. On films that had at least one female director (some films have co-directors), 53 percent of the writers on those films were women, too, compared with 10 percent of writers on films that only had men in the director's chair. Similarly, on female-led films, 32 percent of editors were female, compared with 19 percent of editors on male-led films.

"People feel most comfortable working with those who look like they do," she said, calling the director's chair a "gateway position" that influences who else gets hired. "That's the unconscious bias that people are talking about so much these days."

What Lauzen found most unsettling in the report, meanwhile, is that fully one-third of the top 250 grossing movies employed either no women or just one woman on these teams of key behind-the-scene roles. While that's a smaller percentage than last year, Lauzen said it's still shocking to think that happens when one-third to over half of the student body at top film schools around the country are women.

Still, she finds it encouraging that there's so much of a spotlight on the issue now.

ADVERTISEMENT